HUMSI — Human Security Initiative

Human Impact Project

A living database documenting reported immigration enforcement incidents and their human impact.

Kilmar A.G.: Salvadoran father wrongly deported to CECOT prison despite court order

Kilmar Abrego Garcia, a Salvadoran father whose son has autism, was wrongly deported to a Salvadoran prison and later returned to the U.S.; he now fights a new push to send him to Liberia instead of Costa Rica.

Oct 6, 2026Sacramento, CACountry of origin: Mexico

Kilmar A.G.: Salvadoran father wrongly deported to CECOT prison despite court order
Photo via CBS News

Kilmar Abrego Garcia, a Salvadoran national who lived in Maryland with his U.S. citizen wife and young son who has autism, was arrested in Baltimore in March 2025 and deported to El Salvador's CECOT prison despite a 2019 court order protecting him from removal. US District Judge Paula Xinis ruled the government had 'no legal authority' to arrest, detain, or deport him, calling it a 'grievous error' that 'shocks the conscience,' and ordered his return; his lawyer denied any gang ties and said he had never been charged with a crime. Following public pressure and a Supreme Court order, he was returned to the U.S. in June 2025, after which federal prosecutors indicted him on human smuggling charges in Tennessee. Costa Rica offered him refugee status in August 2025, but the administration instead pursued deporting him to Liberia. A judge ordered his release from ICE custody in December 2025 after finding government lawyers misled the court, later blocking his re-detention and deportation to Liberia, and a federal judge dismissed the smuggling charges in May 2026 as a vindictive response to his legal challenges, a ruling the government is appealing. A hearing meant to determine whether he would be deported to Liberia was abruptly canceled, as his legal team seeks a permanent injunction and argues he should instead be sent to Costa Rica.

Timeline

Oct 6, 2026—Court hearing in Greenbelt, Maryland on potential deportation to Liberia abruptly canceled as legal team seeks permanent injunction
May 2026—Federal judge dismissed the smuggling charges, ruling them a vindictive response to his legal challenges; government appeals to Sixth Circuit
Dec 2025—Judge ordered his release from ICE custody after finding government lawyers misled the court, and blocked re-detention and deportation to Liberia
Aug 2025—Costa Rica offered him refugee status, but administration pursued deportation to Liberia instead
Jun 1, 2025—Returned to the US following a Supreme Court order and public pressure
Jun 2025—Federal prosecutors indicted him on human smuggling charges in Tennessee
Apr 6, 2025—Judge Paula Xinis ruled the deportation unlawful and ordered his return to the US
Mar 15, 2025—Arrested in Baltimore and deported to El Salvador's CECOT prison despite a 2019 court order protecting him
Suggest a correction, comment, or update

Tags

Sources

Show 37 more sources ↓
Similar Incidents

Loading…

More incidents in California